West Caldwell Pizza Delivery

Who doesn’t love pizza, right? But, if you’re a pizza fanatic you know that no two slices are the same. Every place uses its signature touch to make an authentic pie. At Boardwalk Pizza we stand out among the other West Caldwell pizza delivery restaurants in the area because we bring pizza from two big cities right to the West Caldwell area.

What makes Boardwalk Pizza special?

Pizza lovers are serious about their pies. There are some that love the thin New York City style crust while others are Chicago all the way, eating only deep dish style pizza. At Boardwalk pizza, we deliver both – literally. Come in for your favorite New York or Chicago style pizza or call us for pizza delivery. Either way, we won’t disappoint.

For the New York lovers, choose from a variety of meat and vegetarian toppings that will have you fighting for the last slice. With our hand-tossed dough, stretched out thin (of course), our NYC-style pizza cooks up bubbly and delicious.

You don’t need to go to the windy city to dig into a Chicago-style pizza. We may be hundreds of miles away from Chicago, but this pizza is the real deal. With 2 ½ pounds of mozzarella cheese stuffed between two layers, you taste exactly why Boardwalk Pizza stands out among other restaurants along the boardwalk and among other West Caldwell Pizza places. These pizzas take about 40 minutes to cook, so be sure to order early so no one gets “hangry”.

If you don’t have time to wait for a deep-dish pizza but aren’t in the mood for a New York style pizza either, try the 12-inch skillet pizza. Just as the name suggests, these are made in a cast iron skillet and are cooked to bubbly, crispy perfection. Add any meat or veggie toppings you like to personalize this pizza to your taste buds.

Whichever pizza you choose it will be made with fresh dough that’s never been frozen. We also use the best tomatoes because we know every detail about where they come from, including the canning process.

Specialty Pizzas & Popular Picks

At Boardwalk Pizza we recognize that everyone’s taste buds are different. That’s why we offer specialty pizzas for our customers who like to turn it up a notch in the flavor department.

If you’re a meat lover, try our signature Boom Boom Pizza. It’s topped with chicken cutlets, bacon, and our homemade Boom Boom sauce. Can’t decide what topping you want on your pizza? That’s why there’s the Everything Pizza, topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and bacon. It’s a fan favorite at Boardwalk Pizza!

Don’t worry, we didn’t forget about the vegetarians. Our loaded veggie pizza brings the flavors of tri-colored peppers, onions, fresh mushrooms, spinach, and diced tomatoes into each and every slice. If you’re looking to indulge, our penne vodka pizza is just the thing. Penne pasta is tossed in our signature vodka sauce and topped with mozzarella. Once you try it, you’ll be coming back for seconds!

It’s not just the unique flavor combinations that make Boardwalk Pizza a pizza lover’s paradise among West Caldwell pizza places, but also the variety of pizza sizes we offer. If you’re not in the mood to share, our 8” personal pan pizza could be just for you or maybe you want to grab a quick slice, whether it’s just cheese or of the specialty gourmet variety.

If you’re calling for West Caldwell pizza delivery and have the whole family over, choose from our 12” or 18” round pizzas with your favorite topping or 16” square Sicilian pizza or 24” Jumbo Boardwalk style pizza.

For those with a gluten sensitivity or allergy, we offer gluten-free crusts that you can top with your favorites. They’re so good that many people can’t even tell the difference!

Other Menu Items at Boardwalk Pizza

While we love bragging about our pizza, there are many other items available on the Boardwalk Pizza menu. Italian favorites like shrimp parmigiana, Zuppa di clams over spaghetti and cheese ravioli are always available as well as burgers and hot and cold heroes. We also serve stromboli and calzones, with plenty to share!

For the calorie conscious, there are several signature salads to choose from including the bruschetta salad topped with tomatoes and fresh mozzarella or the house chopped salad.

Don’t forget our appetizers and be sure to save room for dessert. You wouldn’t want to miss out on the Italian donuts or Nutella pizza!

If you’re having a party, let Boardwalk Pizza cater your special occasion with our pasta trays, sandwiches, salads and more. Whether you’re calling for pizza delivery or stopping in to dine, Boardwalk Pizza is the treat your taste buds are longing for.

We’re open seven days a week! Stop in, give us a call or order online.